Hey Tj,
Since you stated that the machine hasn't been in use for a while, try moving the rollers by hand or switch the "cue lever" on and off. The cue lever should move the rollers within about 1mm to the capstan surface. They should move freely with very little resistance.
If you have difficulty moving the cue lever or the rollers by hand, look at the lifters to be sure they're motion isn't being somehow obstructed. You might remove the headblock to get a better look.
If those seem to be moving freely, it could be the plunger at the top of the machine.
Open the machine back and top cover. Facing the back of the machine, the plunger is just to the right of the transformer box with dominates the top/center of the machine. Try putting the machine in play (with one of the tensioners pushed down) and see if the plunger pushes out and in when the machine is stopped. If the plunger doesn't do this, check all the fuses and try to move the plunger manually. It could be stuck in and a little pushing might free it up.
If you have a service manual, go to the section on the Stoper Position Adjustment. With the stopper plate removed, try moving the plunger by hand. It should take a little force to push it in and spring right back out when released.
There's a pretty good picture of the entire mechanism on the page for Pressure Roller Adjustment. Most of this stuff is totally obscured by the capstan motor and there's little chance that these mechanisms are so gummed up that it would prevent the rollers from moving (keep you fingers crossed on this one).
Well give those things a try and let us know how it goes.